This is part two of my book discussion with my daughters Carlen and Courtney.
You can read part one here.
With a week between conversations, the girls added a few books they had forgotten and
we had an equally grand time. It bolstered my estimation of the books read during their
childhood. I found their reading history wide and varied.
Parenting can be all-consuming and
often we only see the faintest brushstrokes of the life canvas our children are painting
but some days we catch the briefest of glimpses of how the portrait is taking shape.
In an instant we are reminded of when we first laid eyes on them and believed
they were a masterpiece.
Now all these years later, the truth remains but the visual is more
breathtaking than imagined.
I adored this time with my girls.
As to not be outdone by their brother, they chose to display their selfie love
with Caleb-like photo antics.
Me: Okay girls, let’s get right down to business.
What did you forget to mention from the last conversation?
Carlen: Favorite all-time read aloud: The Search for Delicious.
Court: The Wind in the Willows.
Me: The Wind in the Willows was great but it took such a long time to read.
Carlen: It was a fun read aloud because you didn’t do any accents.
Me: Hey, watch it!
Me: Middle school is a period of time when many people start to not
What is it about middle school and what were some of those
books that you were required to read?
Court: I remember reading A Day No Pig Would Die and it was quite graphic.
It was good but still a bit much.
I think it depended on your teacher and their preferences. In sixth grade,
I remember reading Huckleberry Finn which had a lot of language in it.
I also read To Kill A Mockingbird around that same time as well.
I seem to remember reading a lot of Steinbeck.
Court: It definitely was teacher dependent.
Carlen read Persepolis in middle school,
I didn’t read it until high school.
Carlen: By the time I got to high school, I was really burnt out on reading. Especially after
my freshman year, we read so many books with such intensely hard racial issues.
It was difficult to be the only person of color in class.
Court: Oh yeah. It gets kind of old being the voice for your race.
Me: Yes, all eyes on you.
Court: Freshman year, we spent a lot of time reading Eye on the Prize and watching the film. We also read a book from a young local author The Girl Who Fell From the Sky and
The Secret Life of Bees.
Oh and we read Fences.
Carlen: I loved my freshman English teacher she was very passionate about reading
books about different cultures. We read The Color Purple, The House on Mango Street,
When the Emperor Was Divine and Night.
After awhile I asked her if I could read some other types of
It was not until my senior year when we could read books of our own choosing
as long as they were varied in genre.
That’s when I began to enjoy reading again.
Before senior year, I went into a long phase of reading comic books. Ha.
I just needed a break.
I wore out my copies of Calvin and Hobbes.
Me: Depending on your life experience or season of life, books can be powerful
but also emotionally exhausting if they don’t arrive at the right time..
Tell me some of your favorite books over the years.
Carlen: The Catcher in the Rye.
Court: I know you are supposed to love that book, but I hated it.
Carlen: I think it is one of those books you love or hate. It’s okay.
Carlen: I loved Of Mice and Men, Bridge to Terabithia, Regarding
The Fountain, How to Win Friends and Influence People, My Sister’s Keeper,
The Hunger Games, any book by John Maxwell, Holes or any book by
Louis Sachar, Jerry Spinelli or Shel Silverstein.
I also loved authors Ellen Hopkins and Laurie Halse Anderson.
Court: For me I would say, A Corner of the Universe, A Series of Unfortunate Events,
The Mysterious Benedict Society, Gone Girl, A Change of Heart, Among
The Hidden, Beastly (totally boycotted the movie). Room was a book where
I really didn’t like some of the characters but it still was really good.
Me: I couldn’t wait to share Nancy Drew with the two of you.
Why wouldn’t you give her a chance?
Court: I had Nate the Great, that was enough for me.
Carlen: Okay, The Box Car Children was pushing it with me.
I think I read about 5 of those books.Those books were so old.
I just was never into mystery as a genre.
I liked playing Clue but that was about all.
Carlen: OH! Columbine by Dave Cullen, Courtney and I
both read that book a few summers ago.
It completely changed my whole view of the media.
We never know the whole story.
Court: The book is laid out so well and is divided into different
categories. It was of course really sad but very good at the same
Carlen: I bawled all the way through the book.
Me: Do you ever read books over again?
Court: I don’t usually read books again.
The only books I have read repeatedly are A Corner in the Universe
and Anne Frank: The Diary of A Young Girl.
Carlen: I think I read Holes about 7 times and even listened to the audio tape.
I read Regarding the Fountain a lot, it is so funny.
Calvin and Hobbes: Something Under the Bed Is Drooling, I read it to pieces.
I read Out of the Dust several times. Karen Hesse writes amazing poetry.
Me: Let the battle begin: Book or movie first?
Court: (stands up) Read the book first! I like to go into a book with anticipation.
I like not knowing what is going to happen. There are more details in the book.
Even if changes are made in the movie, it makes more sense because you
have the book as the explanation. A movie may have plot holes which do
not make sense unless you have read the book. Reading the book after seeing
the movie, I doubt I would pay as much attention to details because I have already
seen a visual outline of the book.
Carlen: Watch the movie first. When I read My Sister’s Keeper first,
I was devastated when I saw how they changed the book and the ending.
Now, I see the movie and I can enjoy it for what it is. I know I
will probably enjoy the book more but reading it after the fact, makes
the movie experience fuller.
I am more of a movie buff anyway.
Court: Yeah, I am the book lover.
So this makes sense.
Caleb: Can you tell if a book is good by looking at it?
Carlen: Absolutely not. One of my favorite books, has the most
Courtney: No, I remember when we had a book club and all of us
wanted to read this 101 Dalmatian chapter book based on the cover.
The book was horrible. All the moms made us read it anyway.
Me: I think it was probably because we secretly didn’t want you girls
to pick the book in the first place. I admit, we were mean.
Me: Court, you have an uncanny way of reading books sometimes
years before they become huge hits. I had a great track record
of finding children books before the masses when you both were
What’s your secret?
Court: I don’t know. I am always on the look out.
I read book lists. I search the library’s new books.
I read anything that has a book list and see what strikes
Me: Last questions, what are reading now and what have you
been meaning to read?
It’s crazy but I wanna finish East of Eden.
I have like 20 pages left.
Me: Court, that was like 2 summers ago.
Finish it already.
Court: I know, I know.
Carlen: I am reading Gone Girl and Outliers.
Me: Girls, it has been the most fun to talk to you
It was my hope that you would love books as much as
Let’s keep the conversation going.
Carlen: Next time we should talk about movies.
Court: Oooo, that would be fun.
Me: Or maybe debate whether book covers should
be changed to the movie poster?
I vote an emphatic no!
Carlen: Yes, in most cases.
Court:No, no, no, definitely not!
I didn’t like it when they changed the cover of
Holes or The Hunger Games.
Me: On opposite sides again, I see.
Until next time.
Now I have the task of turning
all these sheets of notes into a blog post
and adding dozens of links.
Wow, you have read a lot of books
and I know I won’t be able to add them all.
(I didn’t…aren’t you glad?!
I love you, my sweets.
Carlen: I love you Mom.
This post is apart of the 31 days…yet again series
about books. You can find the entire series here.